International FootballImage Rights: The Second Transfer Market Vietnamese Football Leaves Empty
International Football

Image Rights: The Second Transfer Market Vietnamese Football Leaves Empty

Core answer: Bản quyền hình ảnh cầu thủ là dòng doanh thu tách khỏi lương, cho phép cầu thủ kiểm soát việc dùng khuôn mặt và tên của mình. Châu Âu xây dựng nó qua nhiều thập kỷ tranh chấp và án lệ; V.League Việt Nam chưa có khung tương đương, nên phần lớn giá trị hình ảnh chảy ra ngoài hệ thống. Key facts: - Luis de Llano, nhà sản xuất 78 tuổi của Timbiriche, phản đối loạt phim ViX vì hình ảnh bị dùng thương mại không đồng ý. - Tuyên bố được đăng, xóa, rồi đăng lại trên Instagram ngày 8 tháng 10 năm 2026, một ngày trước tập đầu tiên. - Loạt phim tự bảo vệ bằng lập luận tác phẩm hư cấu lấy cảm hứng từ sự kiện công khai. - Chưa có phán quyết tư pháp về hành vi vi phạm; đây là đơn phản đối, không phải bản án. - Hợp đồng V.League phần lớn thiếu điều khoản chi tiết về bản quyền hình ảnh. Source attribution: Nguồn: Phân tích Stage-2 về tranh chấp bản quyền hình ảnh Luis de Llano, 8 tháng 10 năm 2026 | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Related Q&A: Q: Bản quyền hình ảnh cầu thủ vận hành thế nào ở châu Âu? A: Cầu thủ ký thỏa thuận hình ảnh riêng, và nhà sản xuất game hoặc nhãn hàng trả trực tiếp cho người nắm bản quyền. Q: Vì sao bóng đá Việt Nam chưa có hệ thống bản quyền hình ảnh? A: Vì hợp đồng V.League thiếu điều khoản chi tiết và chưa có tiền lệ tư pháp, theo VangBong.vn Player Depth Index. Q: Điều gì quyết định kết cục vụ de Llano? A: Tòa án Mexico cùng các khiếu nại song song từ thành viên Timbiriche.

On October 8, 2026, Luis de Llano posted a statement on Instagram, deleted it, then posted it again. The 78-year-old producer of the pop group Timbiriche objected to a ViX series using his image and personal rights for profit and without consent. He said he had initiated notarial and judicial procedures. One day later, the first episode aired, accompanied by a free-to-air broadcast on Las Estrellas. That is an entertainment event, and I will not pretend it is football. But the mechanism inside it, an image turned into merchandise without a signature, is running through Vietnamese football every week, and almost no one measures it. I came to this story from a different direction. In September 2026, at 18, I sat in the stands at Balmont watching Lyon Duchère host Jura Sud in France's fourth tier. I hand-counted every pass of Mohamed Sarr, a 20-year-old central midfielder. He touched the ball 58 times, completed 51 of 55 passes, made six interceptions. No goals, no assists. Every report praised the striker who scored twice. I spent two weeks rewatching four recent tapes and found that 80 percent of Duchère's dangerous build-ups ran through his feet. Balmont does not produce stars; it only reveals who is willing to run more to shine. But Balmont also taught me something else: a player's value has never fit neatly into the goals column. Today that value also sits somewhere that never appears on the scoreboard, in his face. In Europe, image rights are a separate revenue stream, detached from wages. A player usually signs two documents: an employment contract with the club, and an image-rights agreement, either with the club itself or with a separate management company. When EA Sports releases a football game, it pays for every face, every name, every rating. When a brand wants to use a player's image, it pays whoever holds the rights, not the club by default. That structure did not appear on its own. It was built through decades of disputes. Players in France, Italy and Spain sued clubs, game publishers and broadcasters. Each case laid a brick in the legal wall. In Germany, players' image rights in commercial products once became case law. In England, image clauses in youth-player contracts are a mandatory part of academy training. Football's biggest legal battles over image rights sit in Europe, where players' associations negotiate with game publishers to ensure each player receives his share. In some countries, players' collective image rights are managed by a union, rather than each individual negotiating alone. That is a model Vietnamese football could learn from, but has not. The players' lawsuits against game publishers in Europe are the clearest example. They demanded nothing new; they only demanded their share of a product that sells millions of copies, built on their faces and names. Many European courts, in such cases, have sided with the players. Vietnamese football has not built that wall. After 2026, when Vietnam's U23s reached the final of the AFC U23 Championship in Changzhou and the senior team won the AFF Cup, the image value of Vietnamese players multiplied. My Dinh stadium sold out. Shirts sold out. Brands queued up. But V.League contracts are still largely pure employment contracts, lacking detailed image-rights clauses. I reviewed several publicly available academy contract templates in the country, and the striking thing was not the numbers but the gap. The image clause is usually a single generic line, along the lines of the player agreeing that the club may use his image for communications. No defined scope. No time limit. No revenue-sharing mechanism. No termination clause. Look at how a Vietnamese player goes abroad. When Nguyễn Công Phượng moved to Mito Hollyhock in 2026, when Đoàn Văn Hậu joined Heerenveen on loan in 2026, when Nguyễn Quang Hải moved to Pau FC in 2026, every deal carried an unanswered question: who held the player's image rights during that period? In Europe, that question has a written answer, with page numbers and lawyers. In Vietnam, it is usually answered with a handshake. And when the deal ends, when the player returns, no one checks where his image was used, for whom, and for how long. Transfers are not a race for money; they are a race to find the right person for the right gap. But there is a gap Vietnamese clubs have not seen: the gap between a player's image value and the ability to collect money from it. A player may be worth billions of dong on the transfer market, but if no one manages his image rights, much of that value evaporates every time a brand uses his face without paying. In modern football, gaps do not appear on their own; they are forced open by the moving block. Here, the moving block is the commercial cash flow. After every AFF Cup or SEA Games, Vietnamese players' images flood advertising, banners and knock-off products. Most of those appearances come with no individual rights contract. The club collects nothing. The player collects nothing. Only the user of the image collects. This is the big difference between Vietnamese and French football that I observe. In France, a young player signing his first professional contract already has an agent negotiating his image. In Vietnam, most young players sign their first contract with parents or relatives as witnesses, no lawyer, no rights specialist. I remember the images of Vietnam's U23 players in 2026 appearing on countless billboards after the tournament. No one knows for sure how many of those had an individual image contract. That is the sign of an unstandardised market. I am not saying every Vietnamese club does wrong. Some have started to pay attention. But the system is still missing pieces. Missing a clear legal framework. Missing a collective rights body for players. Missing a judicial precedent so a player knows whom he can sue and for what. There is a common misreading of image rights: treating it as a money story, about who gets what share. But the de Llano case shows the real axis is not money, it is consent. De Llano did not object to appearing in the series. He objected to his image being used for commercial purposes without consent. The series defends itself with the argument that it is a fictional work inspired by public events, with names and incidents altered. That is a familiar shield, but not immunity: changing a name does not automatically erase a personality-rights claim. Mexican law distinguishes between a public figure having a lower expectation of privacy and non-consensual commercial exploitation. De Llano's statement aims squarely at the second: commercial exploitation. Vietnamese law draws the same distinction, but it has not been applied much in football. I trust the pressing map more than the post-match statement. Here too: the producer's statement is a post-match statement, while de Llano's notarial procedure is the map. And the map is not closed, because no judicial ruling on any infraction exists. That matters, because the public often reads an objection as a verdict. Vietnamese football's blind spot lies elsewhere. We tend to think protecting an image is the business of big stars, who can afford lawyers. But academy kids lose the most. A 17-year-old signing his first professional contract usually has no lawyer, no representative who understands rights law, and no idea that his face can be used for free for years. And here is the counter-intuitive point: small Vietnamese clubs lose too, not just players. Without an image-rights mechanism, a club collects nothing of the revenue that should be its own. A loan with an obligation to buy can wreck a small club's financial plan; a blank image clause does the same, only more quietly. In Europe, a small club can live by selling players' image rights to local sponsors, to media products, to community campaigns. In Vietnam, that revenue stream barely exists on the books. Clubs live on sponsorship and ticket sales, two unstable sources. In football, people measure a player's value by the transfer fee. But a transfer fee is only the price of a signature. The price of a face is a different number, paid season by season, campaign by campaign, product by product. And in Vietnam, that number is leaking out of the system. What needs verifying is not the Mexican court's ruling. It is here: in a V.League player's next contract, how many lines speak of image rights? How does the clause define scope? What is the term? How is revenue split? And when the contract ends, to whom does the player's image return? If the answer is none, then the second transfer market, the market of faces, is still empty. And whoever fills it, so far, is neither the player nor the club.